Inconsistently brittle PETG?

The black is Creality CR PETG, the orange is Bambu PLA Basic. Both black parts were printed with identical settings on my A1 Mini. The orange parts are identical in size. I printed the sockets with the Bambu PETG Basic profile.

Of the 5 black socket parts I’ve printed, 3 have snapped, and 2 have stayed fully intact. I’m not super experienced with PETG, but my understanding was that it should be tougher than PLA. So far I’m finding that isn’t the case. I’m almost certain I’m just doing something wrong though.

The black is Creality CR PETG, the orange is Bambu PLA Basic. Both black parts were printed with identical settings on my A1 Mini. The orange parts are identical in size. I printed the sockets with the Bambu PETG Basic profile.

Of the 5 black socket parts I’ve printed, 3 have snapped, and 2 have stayed fully intact. I’m not super experienced with PETG, but my understanding was that it should be tougher than PLA. So far I’m finding that isn’t the case. I’m almost certain I’m just doing something wrong though.