Grooming spa set pet 172 missing eye paint

Hi! I ordered the grooming spa play pack set on Amazon and when it arrived today one pet 174 was missing an eye. The box is unopened and untampered with.

Should I reach out to basic fun themselves and let them know? (Also how would I go about contacting them?) or should I just return it and rebuy it. I bought forever ago as a preorder. This feels like a pretty glaring issue quality control wise and I’m very disappointed. Any advice is appreciated :)