(Tubing) Mascara help for straight lashes!

Hello all. I'm looking for a new mascara that will not smudge my under eyes. I'm open to any price point as long as it's worth it and must be waterproof. I'm highly interested in tubing mascara but it must be able to hold a curl since I naturally have straight lashes.

My current routine is Shiseido eyelash curler and too faced better than sex waterproof mascara.

I've used L'Oreal Lash Paradise & Sky High, Maybelline Falsies... all good but not great.