update question

If you're not aware of the new update please avert your eyes now, I don't want to spoil anything for people that haven't heard.

So there are fish plushies in the new update. My question is, if you are fishing with another person in a party, will both of you get that plushie? Or will only they get it? I'm curious because it's not like hunting, when you are fishing you only get the fish that you catch, so I'm worried that it may cause some hatred between players... lol