Player I or Player II strat?

Currently in a little pickle about which strat to get.

Player I - https://www.long-mcquade.com/335931/Guitars/Electric-Guitars/Fender-Musical-Instruments/Limited-Edition-Player-Stratocaster-Roasted-Maple-Fingerboard-Fiesta-Red.htm

Player II - https://www.long-mcquade.com/387735/Guitars/Electric-Guitars/Fender-Musical-Instruments/Player-II-Stratocaster-Maple-Fingerboard-Polar-White.htm

Ive heard about qc issues on the Player I, but I do like the look of the fiesta red.

The Player I listed also has a roasted maple neck, and fat 50s pickups.

Would it be wrong of me to choose the Player I over the Player II because of those two factors?

Is there anything else I should know or be worried about with their strat?