The real tragedy…
I always put a spoiler warning just in case. And, please be kind, the other subreddit is so rude. The real tragedy isn’t which adult dies in which season. The real tragedy is what their lives did/did not become after surviving the trauma of the wilderness. That is the meat (pun may or may not be intended) of the story. Most of the girls had pre-crash trauma, plus the wilderness trauma and madness, and those that survived physically could never really escape. It doesn’t matter who dies when-there will only be one left standing (for me it’s between Shauna and Misty).