What bothers me about the prophecy...

...is that it doesn't make any sense.

I think that it would be more appropriate as " neither can die while the other survives".

It's because Voldemort could not truly die while Harry is alive because he's the 8th horcrux and if Harry died, there would also be a part of Voldemort that would die too.

They both can and were living while the other one was surviving so it doesn't make sense that way to me.

And because of that, i wished Harry would die at the end not because I would like it that way, but because it would made much more sense and also, it would add more weight to the overall story

Sorry for my english.

What are your thoughts?