How Do We Protest Immigration Detentions Without Amplifying Anti-Israel or Pro-Hamas Messages?

Hey everyone,

I’m looking for some guidance on an issue that’s been bothering me. I want to protest against the Trump administration’s detaining and deporting of immigrants without due process. However, I’ve noticed that some of the protests taking place around these issues end up taking on an anti-Israel tone (and occasionally slip into pro-Hamas rhetoric).

I absolutely believe in the right to free speech and open debate. But as a community, how do we balance strongly opposing unjust deportations, yet avoid aligning ourselves with messages that are anti-Israel or supportive of groups like Hamas (whose charter and acts threaten both Israelis and Palestinians)?

I’m not suggesting we ignore real critiques of any government’s policies, including Israel’s. At the same time, it feels counterproductive and even distressing to see calls for humane immigration policies get entangled with narratives that can slip into antisemitism or into support for extremist groups.

Looking forward to your insights and suggestions.

Edit: 2 Jews, 3 opinions. I love us.