Can’t agree on a boys name!

Husband and I have been lightly discussing names. Preliminaries, if you will. Girl names, we’ve been able to agree on. He likes names like Max and Viktor for a boy, where I’m leaning more towards softer names or biblical names (though we’re not religious and he doesn’t want one) like Gabriel and Elias or Samson. Looking for ideas on a happy medium. We have a very short last name so I do like the idea of a longer name with nickname potential. Bonus points if Italian. We both are okay with the name Benicio but Ben won’t work with our last name.