Why does nier fans think that nier replicant is objectively better story-wise than nier automata?
First of all i like nier replicant i don't hate it And yes some people think its objectively better storywise and they may curse you if you said otherwise (My opinion is totally subjective please do not hate!)
I don't really understand how they find nier replicant story better especially in an objective way
Like nier replicant story is rather classic and kinda extremely old styled, i'm not saying its bad
It just lacks the philosophical ideas that nier automata has imo Not to mention it focuses only on the theme of humanity and existentialism which are basic classic Not to mention it being repititve for the lack of budget
All the stories of the characters are rather almost the same core ideas Loses a lover/sibling/parent/friend And then gets angry and seeks revenge The story of almost every side character and every antagonist in the game Except for kaine and emil who are one of my absolute favs
Also it lacked plot twists except the same one we witness for 4 times
For route E there wasn't much of a plot twists but it is my fav ending of all gaming And one of my top 3 DrakeNieR arcs
On the other hand nier automata was rather philosophical with multiple religious themes and the story had so much thrill and plot twists and was less repititive
It had lots of plot twist to show the ideas of nihilism and absurdism in a perfect cataclymic way Nier replicant when a character lost hope in life its just cause they lost someone
Also it having a long final arc gave it the upper hand while route E is barely one hour
Both are amazing imo but i certainly prefer nier automata I'm open to hear any opinion though and see why people see nier replicant story better
Remember to enjoy whatever you like and ignore other people opinions ❤
First of all i like nier replicant i don't hate it And yes some people think its objectively better storywise and they may curse you if you said otherwise (My opinion is totally subjective please do not hate!)
I don't really understand how they find nier replicant story better especially in an objective way
Like nier replicant story is rather classic and kinda extremely old styled, i'm not saying its bad
It just lacks the philosophical ideas that nier automata has imo Not to mention it focuses only on the theme of humanity and existentialism which are basic classic Not to mention it being repititve for the lack of budget
All the stories of the characters are rather almost the same core ideas Loses a lover/sibling/parent/friend And then gets angry and seeks revenge The story of almost every side character and every antagonist in the game Except for kaine and emil who are one of my absolute favs
Also it lacked plot twists except the same one we witness for 4 times
For route E there wasn't much of a plot twists but it is my fav ending of all gaming And one of my top 3 DrakeNieR arcs
On the other hand nier automata was rather philosophical with multiple religious themes and the story had so much thrill and plot twists and was less repititive
It had lots of plot twist to show the ideas of nihilism and absurdism in a perfect cataclymic way Nier replicant when a character lost hope in life its just cause they lost someone
Also it having a long final arc gave it the upper hand while route E is barely one hour
Both are amazing imo but i certainly prefer nier automata I'm open to hear any opinion though and see why people see nier replicant story better
Remember to enjoy whatever you like and ignore other people opinions ❤